An Occult Education Through Chess (Part 4)

Any topics primarily focused on metaphysics can be discussed here, in a generally casual way, where conversations may take unexpected turns.
User avatar
AshvinP
Posts: 6630
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2021 5:00 am
Location: USA

An Occult Education Through Chess (Part 4)

Post by AshvinP »

''Chess is a fairy tale of 1,001 blunders.'' – Savielly Tartakower, GM

Thrown Into the Unintuitive Flows

Once we have done some work deconstructing the imaginative, feeling, and willing (bodily and social) spectrums of our intuitive life, we can more keenly sense what it means to lack intuitive orientation within the primary flow. This orientation only feels somewhat lucid and refined within our narrow subflow of mental images, where there is a high degree of correlation (responsiveness) with our intuitive intents. All the psychic and physical constraints illustrated in the previous part, which come into focus when we try to ‘ripple out’ our intents beyond our mental subflow, introduce a level of indirection between these ‘inputs’ (intuitive intents) and the flow of emotional or sensory ‘outputs’ (perceptions). This indirection diminishes the input-output correlation and our corresponding orientation within the flow. Within the feeling and willing spectrums, it is as if more leeway is opened for our inputs to diffuse into the ‘atmosphere’ and return to meet us later in unrecognizable output forms. The inputs and outputs grow increasingly ‘out of phase’, just as in our 4x4 delayed aperture metaphor. The mental images receding from the horizon of our consciousness that we observe and contemplate are then only the reverberations of long-receded gameplay, encoding habitual movement patterns to which we have lost intuitive sensitivity.

Returning to the public speaking imagination, let's imagine the unruly audience member felt impelled to shout over us because we bullied him in childhood. Yet we forgot all about this deeper connection over the years, and thus we felt it as a completely unexpected, unintuitive interruption in our intended flow. It is a similar feeling when our bodily processes ‘revolt’, preventing us from navigating toward desired states, and we have little intuitive sense of how our previous inputs contributed to the disharmonious output stream. Do we usually have any clear sense of why or how a throbbing headache entered this output stream, for example? We are often beset by aches, injuries, illnesses, and misfortunes that seem to enter our flow from an orthogonal direction, unrelated to anything we can remember doing. Perhaps we experience a similar feeling with many of the global events we read about in the news. In such events, however, we can barely even imagine how our previous intuitive inputs would have contributed to the outputs. They feel like completely independent happenings of the primary 8x8 flow. For that reason, we ascribe these events to chance, destiny, or the ‘evildoing' of others and accept the corresponding pain, uncertainty, confusion, and frustration as inherent aspects of our existence.

It is the same lack of intuitive orientation that is present when everything is running smoothly: when we feel healthy, our wealth is growing, our relationships are improving, we are gaining new insights in our fields of inquiry, and so on. The main difference is that, in these times, we begin to veil our lack of orientation by ascribing the positive developments to our hard work, cleverness, superior qualities, and so forth. Instead of recognizing that many of these developments enter our flow just as mysteriously as the negative ones, we take credit for them and thus begin to take them for granted. We imagine we can sustain and build on them simply by navigating the flow with our current qualities and capacities, continuing along our current trajectory. That puffed-up stance leaves us in a pitiful state of lacking orientation within the flow, but not even knowing it. When things are no longer running smoothly, and we are forced to recognize our lack of orientation, we also don’t know how to regain it. We then rely on our instincts to kick in, as we begin dreamily modulating our inputs such that a point of balance is restored, i.e., we take rest, move more carefully, refrain from excessive food and drink, try to learn about our current state, try to mend the fences with our neighbors, and so on.

Yet that balance is maintained only briefly before another jagged interruption in the smooth flow inevitably occurs. This dynamic can be experienced acutely in a game of Chess. When we attain a winning position, we often become complacent and overconfident in our ability to navigate the game flow seamlessly, as if on autopilot. It becomes a classic case of ‘counting our chickens before they hatch’, anticipating a smooth flow that will somehow propagate itself without our continual inner effort. When that inner stance is adopted, it won’t be long before we lose concentration and blunder a piece or the entire game. Our pride in the winning position veils an underlying lack of orientation to the present game flow. The following short clip provides an example of how that dynamic can unfold:





In our occult education, we can leverage such experiences to attain a more refined sense of the archetypal inner dynamic that influences our flow in the most varied life circumstances. When we act recklessly and injure ourselves, for example, it is unlikely that our injury will heal in a smooth and linear process. Once the pain subsides, it likely won’t be long before we feel ‘in control’ again, fall prey to our usual habits, and instinctively use the injured member too forcefully, setting back the healing process by some number of days. Likewise, if we smooth over a dispute with our friend or partner and our relationship with them is humming along smoothly, it won’t be long before we say or do something insensitive and reopen the old wounds. In that sense, as soon as our intuitive flow starts to feel a little more stable and comfortable, we instinctively fall back on our untransformed patterns of thinking and acting, which quickly throw us back into the oscillatory loop between optimal moves and blunders. The tip of our navigatory flow is then experienced like the second arm of a double pendulum, chaotically oscillating, overcorrecting to one side or the other, and only rarely crossing through a point of balance.

Full essay - https://spiritanalogies.substack.com/p/ ... -chess-fba
"They only can acquire the sacred power of self-intuition, who within themselves can interpret and understand the symbol... those only, who feel in their own spirits the same instinct, which impels the chrysalis of the horned fly to leave room in the involucrum for antennae yet to come."
User avatar
Federica
Posts: 2767
Joined: Sat May 14, 2022 2:30 pm
Location: Sweden

Re: An Occult Education Through Chess (Part 4)

Post by Federica »

Ashvin wrote:Now we can imagine how ‘perforations’ emerged within this encompassing instinctive orientation, as if an infinite sphere of intuitive ‘luminosity’ was being gradually blotted out in various regions of phenomenal space (this is another angle on the ‘zooming in’ process). Gradually, doubts emerged about the meaning of the transformations experienced in nature, since the soul could no longer feel those transformations as clearly overlapping with the dynamics of its inner experiences. This blotting-out process continued until the surrounding sensory landscape was experienced only as a skeletal lattice, a void of space containing discrete forms that transform from ‘frame to frame’, quite disconnected from the depth of impulses, feelings, and ideas that lived in the soul. Now, the soul had to indirectly approximate the meaning of these broader transformations through its increasingly flattened and shadowy mental images. The growls of nature no longer bestowed upon the soul an instinctive orientation to their significance within the flow, but were replaced by the ‘growls’ of its narrow headspace that we experience as mental images (thoughts). The soul felt that, in some mysterious way, these two growls were connected and that the headspace growls could be used to investigate those of nature.

In that sense, it is this highly perforated intuitive orientation that forms the basis for modern human intelligence, and its navigation of the partial transformations through lucid mental images. Eventually, we were left in a sensory skeletal lattice devoid of instinctive orientation and forced to create replicas of the content that remained in our flattened sensory experience. These replicas were fashioned out of the ‘imaginative substance’ which takes shape from all that we experience through the senses - colors, sounds, smells, tastes, tactile sensations, etc. Our inner voice, for example, is woven from replicas of auditory experiences in our primary language. We could then combine those replicas in various ways, which felt like a partial restoration of our luminous orientation throughout the volume of the intuitive flow. These replicas now lacked the living qualities of the flow and therefore became responsive to our intents, just as it seems easier to sculpt a block of ice than a pool of water or a volume of air. Thus, we could freely utilize our icy replicas to reconstruct some aspects of the living flows, at least up to a limit (which is the limit of inquiries fully mediated by the senses, reified by modern philosophy into fundamental ‘limits of knowledge’).


Thanks for this new episode, Ashvin. Anyone can relate to the roundup of objective examples of debacle you provide - all the ways in which our thoughts fail to wisely orient us in life. In the context of sub-flow versus primary flow, these examples really concretize the vague feeling many are somewhat conscious of, I’m sure, of being dissatisfied with the randomness, defectiveness, short-sightedness, and arbitrariness of their thoughts; The “throwness” of life may be something that many just accept, but closer to the surface of consciousness is the feeling that thoughts tend to land on phenomena like random stickers, like bad quality subtitles to life. They come with a phase gap, they don’t faithfully interpret, they obscure the original phenomenal character, etcetera. I guess the most common treatment to appease these feelings is to resolve to somehow acquire more applicable 'knowledge', in an idealized, abstract future. Unless the discomfort is smeared out, as you say, or drowned in the incessant eventfulness of everyday life. Hence the great value of a precise and traceable phenomenology of the ‘drama of perception and the skeletal lattice’ that you underpin here. I appreciate how it’s very well documented in the books of our familiar experiential flow. It really gives form and substance to the general mood of deaf dissatisfaction with the usual intellect games.

Now I think this is a demanding reading. Insight follows insight, which follows insight, and the pace is quite tight. So I hope there will be ways to facilitate for people a second chance to tackle this initiatory inner work through the cues that constellate the shining panorama you are painting in this series. By the way, do you still like your job?
"In the sense world, every time you have a sensation, it’s a recapitulation of the Fall." Dennis Klocek
User avatar
AshvinP
Posts: 6630
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2021 5:00 am
Location: USA

Re: An Occult Education Through Chess (Part 4)

Post by AshvinP »

Federica wrote: Thu Mar 26, 2026 4:43 pm Now I think this is a demanding reading. Insight follows insight, which follows insight, and the pace is quite tight. So I hope there will be ways to facilitate for people a second chance to tackle these initiatory inner work through the cues that constellate the shining panorama you are painting in this series.
Thanks, Federica.

Yeah, I can sense that tight pace as well, and I think that, apart from my general laziness to work longer on the essays and build a more refined gradient, it is also a drawback of breaking up the essay into short installments like this. A lot of varied insights about the inner dynamics tend to get packed into a short space, and it can feel like jumping from one to another. I mostly hope that anyone who is interested in working through these kinds of essays will patiently work through them as a whole and revisit the installments a few times, realizing that it will take such consistent efforts for them to sink in and really be experienced as a coherent narrative of occult education.

It's interesting because the structure of these kinds of essays naturally begins to resemble the evolutionary dynamics themselves. Each installment begins by recapitulating certain insights that were previously explored, but from a slightly new angle, for example. That isn't necessarily my explicit intention, but the imaginative process generally unfolds that way. Likewise, there ends up being a rhythmic structure of zooming in and out, from a consideration of broader evolutionary trajectories to an exploration of more detailed phenomenological considerations within the imaginative flow. I generally aim for the latter to become more prominent as the installments progress, and the former to remain as a background context for the phenomenology.

By the way, do you still like your job?
Could you elaborate on this question? :)
"They only can acquire the sacred power of self-intuition, who within themselves can interpret and understand the symbol... those only, who feel in their own spirits the same instinct, which impels the chrysalis of the horned fly to leave room in the involucrum for antennae yet to come."
User avatar
Federica
Posts: 2767
Joined: Sat May 14, 2022 2:30 pm
Location: Sweden

Re: An Occult Education Through Chess (Part 4)

Post by Federica »

AshvinP wrote: Thu Mar 26, 2026 5:50 pm Could you elaborate on this question? :)

Well, this is like in the Holy Week's workshop: a question that remains open, not to call for an answer, and I am also not allowed to comment on it so, unfortunately, I can't elaborate :)
"In the sense world, every time you have a sensation, it’s a recapitulation of the Fall." Dennis Klocek
Post Reply