Re: Question about Kastrup's perspective on Freewill
Posted: Fri Apr 02, 2021 1:23 am
To put it bluntly, God has will. Personal separate egos do not. But who are you? You are not your ego, you are God!
I think you pretty much captured the theme of the thread..findingblanks wrote: ↑Fri Apr 02, 2021 3:46 am Haven't read the whole thread yet.
Kastrup is great in showing why "free will" is a red herring.
Kastrap is not great when he then contradicts himself by saying that we are free when we resisit outside determinations.
I certainly agree that the question of freewill has no bearing on metaphysical Idealism. However, I disagree that it is not relevant to how the world looks. The vast majority of people act, behave and judge under the assumption that they and others do have some freewill. And, there is psychological research that supports the idea that a person's belief about freewill affects their judgement and behavior:Astra052 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 02, 2021 6:59 pm I understand why many people are concerned about the issue of free will but honestly I don't understand the point either way? I don't think the free will issue has much of a bearing on idealism and with or without it we can still be idealists. Whether there is free will or not you're always going to do what you want to do. In fact I think a world where free will is possible and one where it isn't probably look almost identical because either way people are doing the things they want to do anyways. The non-free will perspective isn't one where we're being forced against our will to make desicions we don't want to make. I'm an agnostic on the issue and either way I don't think it does anything to impact the idealist position.
If it exists in some form (somewhere in the space between determinism and randomness - if that's even possible), it would manifest in studies, like in the link mentioned above, and many other aspects of everyday life. It mostly depends on what level of decision making/deliberation such freedom might be possible. Though I may have completely misunderstood the question..
I understand why it would be even if you don't believe in free will I think you still understand that people are doing the things they want to do. Either way its the same result and in all honesty doesn't matter a whole lot.ItayNagar wrote: ↑Fri Apr 02, 2021 7:34 pmI certainly agree that the question of freewill has no bearing on metaphysical Idealism. However, I disagree that it is not relevant to how the world looks. The vast majority of people act, behave and judge under the assumption that they and others do have some freewill. And, there is psychological research that supports the idea that a person's belief about freewill affects their judgement and behavior:Astra052 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 02, 2021 6:59 pm I understand why many people are concerned about the issue of free will but honestly I don't understand the point either way? I don't think the free will issue has much of a bearing on idealism and with or without it we can still be idealists. Whether there is free will or not you're always going to do what you want to do. In fact I think a world where free will is possible and one where it isn't probably look almost identical because either way people are doing the things they want to do anyways. The non-free will perspective isn't one where we're being forced against our will to make desicions we don't want to make. I'm an agnostic on the issue and either way I don't think it does anything to impact the idealist position.
https://labs.psych.ucsb.edu/schooler/jo ... -free-will
That raises a whole question whether we should chose our beliefs or metaphysical views based on their philosophical validity or truthfulness, or based on their social or psychological effects and benefits (or may be some compromise between both)?ItayNagar wrote: ↑Fri Apr 02, 2021 7:34 pm I certainly agree that the question of freewill has no bearing on metaphysical Idealism. However, I disagree that it is not relevant to how the world looks. The vast majority of people act, behave and judge under the assumption that they and others do have some freewill. And, there is psychological research that supports the idea that a person's belief about freewill affects their judgement and behavior:
https://labs.psych.ucsb.edu/schooler/jo ... -free-will